Mar 22, 2026; Elmont, New York, USA; New York Islanders defenseman Matthew Schaefer (48) takes a shot against the Columbus Blue Jackets during the second period at UBS Arena. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-Imagn Images
IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Blue Jackets vs Islanders Prediction 11/17/2026 Today’s NHL Picks

Pick details

Columbus vs New York Odds and Matchup Info
MATCHUP Columbus Blue Jackets New York Islanders
Team Records 7-11 9-6
Spread +1.5 -218 -1.5 180
Moneyline +120 -142
Total Over 5.5 (-118) Under 5.5 (-102)
Where UBS Arena, Elmont, NY
When Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Time 07:00 PM EST
TV ESPN+

Blue Jackets vs Islanders Prediction

New York comes into this matchup on a two game winning streak and they have scored 4+ goals in three of their last four. The Islanders are 4-3-2 at home this year, while the Blue Jackets are 1-5-0 on the road. Columbus has lost four in a row, with three of those losses coming by at least two goals. The Blue Jackets have scored two goals or fewer in four of their last five, so give me New York to win at home here.

Columbus Blue Jackets Betting Preview

The Columbus Blue Jackets are 7-11-0 this season after they lost to the Flyers by a score of 4-3 in their last game. Columbus led 2-0 in the first period and they were tied 3-3 after the second, but they allowed the only goal in the third for the loss. The Blue Jackets out shot Philadelphia by a total of 32-21, won 60.8% of the face-offs, and went 0-1 on the power play in the game. Columbus was led by Matthew Knies, who had one goal, while Adam Fantilli also added one goal. Jet Greaves stopped 17 out of 21 shots in the loss.

Prior to that game, Columbus lost to the Lightning by a score of 3-1 and the Panthers by a score of 4-1. The Blue Jackets have scored 2.39 goals per game and they have allowed 3.22 goals against per game, while also going 18.2% on the power play and 73.5% on the penalty kill this season. Kent Johnson has led the team with eight goals and 10 assists, while Zach Werenski has added two goals and 13 assists. Jet Greaves is 2-8-0 with a 3.42 goals against average and an .875 save percentage this season.

New York Islanders Betting Preview

The New York Islanders are 9-6-4 this year after they defeated the Ducks by a score of 6-2 in their last game. New York had their lead cut to 2-1 in the second period, but they scored the next three goals to pull away with the win. The Islanders were out shot by a total of 28-25, won 50.8% of the face-offs, and went 1-3 on the power play in the game. New York was led by Simon Holmstrom, who had three goals, while Matthew Schaefer added three assists. Semyon Varlamov stopped 26 out of 28 shots in the win.

Prior to that game, New York defeated the Kings by a score of 5-2, but lost to the Sharks by a score of 3-2 before that. The Islanders have scored 3.11 goals per game and they have allowed 2.84 goals against per game, while also going 17.2% on the power play and 85.9% on the penalty kill this season. Matthew Schaefer has led the team with six goals and 15 assists, while Bo Horvat has added nine goals and 11 assists. Ilya Sorokin is 7-4-2 with a 2.53 goals against average and a .915 save percentage this year.

Why the New York Islanders will win

  • The Islanders have won eight of their last nine home games against the Blue Jackets.
  • The Blue Jackets have lost each of their last four games.
  • The Blue Jackets have failed to cover the puck line in nine of their last 10 games against Eastern Conference opponents.
  • The Islanders have covered the puck line in three of their last four games against Eastern Conference opponents.
  • The Blue Jackets have lost the second period in each of their last four games as road underdogs against Metropolitan Division opponents when leading after the first period.
2026-27 NHL handicapper records, ranked by profit ($100 base bet).
RankCapperWonLostWin %Profit
1David Racey897454.60%+539
2Jay Yang231658.97%+440
3Chris Ruffolo614855.96%+306
4CD Sports5362.50%+230
5John Ryan9756.25%+120

See the full rankings: Best NHL Handicappers

Total Goals Facts

  • Five of the last six games between two teams from the Metropolitan Division have gone OVER the total goals line.
  • Five of the Blue Jackets’ last six road games against Metropolitan Division opponents have gone UNDER the total goals line.
  • Five of the Islanders’ last six games against opponents on a losing streak have gone UNDER the total goals line.
  • The ‘Over 1.5 Goals Period 1′ market has hit in each of the Islanders’ last six games as favorites against opponents on a losing streak.
  • The ‘Over 2.5 Goals Period 1′ market has hit in three of the Blue Jackets’ last four road games against Eastern Conference opponents.

New York Islanders Player Prop Facts

  • Victor Eklund has scored a goal in four of the Islanders’ last five games.
  • Mathew Barzal has recorded at least one assist in each of his last nine Tuesday night appearances.

Columbus Blue Jackets Player Prop Facts

  • Kent Johnson has scored at least one goal in each of the Blue Jackets’ last three road games against Eastern Conference opponents.
  • Kent Johnson has recorded an assist in six of the Blue Jackets’ last seven games.

Positive Trends

After reviewing the trends, I am comfortable backing the Islanders in this spot. New York is 8-1 in their last nine home games against Columbus and their offense is heating up. The Blue Jackets are on a small losing streak and they have also failed to cover the puck line in nine of their last ten against Eastern Conference opponents. Take the Islanders to get a nice win at home here.

David Racey's Pick: Islanders ML

2026-27 NBA handicapper records, ranked by profit ($100 base bet).
RankCapperWonLostWin %Profit (per $100 bet)
1Jay Briggs462763.01%+1898
2John Ryan15671.43%+846
3Stephen Nover12475.00%+727
4CD Sports12957.14%+194
5Damian Sosh171454.84%+165
6Big Al McMordie302653.57%+164
7Ron Romanelli191654.29%+144

See the full Best NBA Handicappers rankings

Need More? Get Premium Picks

Hot Cappers