Villanova vs Seton Hall Prediction 12/23/2025 Today’s College Basketball Picks

The Villanova Wildcats and the Seton Hall Pirates meet Tuesday in college basketball action from Prudential Center in Newark. Here’s a Villanova vs Seton Hall prediction. We will look at this from a betting perspective and determine the best Villanova vs Seton Hall pick. We will examine the recent form and player performances for both teams, as well as the recent betting trends and streaks pertaining to this matchup. As we conclude, we will tie it all together with a summary that produces a sensible pick for a favorable betting outcome in this game.

Villanova Wildcats Betting Preview

The Wildcats lost to BYU in their opener this year then hit a win streak. Those victories would come versus Queens U, Sacred Heart, Duquesne, La Salle, Old Dominion, Temple and Penn in succession. Villanova would lose to Michigan in game nine, but they’ve since taken out Pitt and Wisconsin. Over 11 games so far this year that gives the Wildcats a 9-2 overall record in the books.

In the Wisconsin game on Friday, the Wildcats blew a 35-22 halftime lead and had to go to overtime to settle a 76-66 victory in the end. Villanova’s leading scorer during the win was Tyler Perkins with 19 points and six rebounds. Matt Hodge added 15 points with six boards and Duke Brennan had 13 points with 11 rebounds and four assists over 39 minutes total.

Seton Hall Pirates Betting Preview

Over on the Seton Hall side, they opened up the year on a nice run. The Pirates took out Saint Peter’s, Wagner, Fairfield, Monmouth, New Haven and NC State in their first six games before a loss to USC. Since then it’s been wins over Washington State, Central Connecticut, Kansas State, Rutgers and Providence for a nice 11-1 overall record through the first 12 games of the year.

In the Providence matchup on Friday, the Pirates entered the second half with a 35-28 edge. Seton Hall was outscored 39-37 the rest of the way but still polished off the win 72-67 in the end. Leading team scorer TK Simpkins finished with 22 points in 31 minutes and Stephon Payne doubled up with 18 points and 16 rebounds in 29 minutes for the Pirates during the victory effort.

Villanova Wildcats @ Seton Hall Pirates Betting Trends: December 23, 2025

Why the Seton Hall Pirates will win

• Seton Hall has won each of its last eight night games against non-AP-ranked opponents.
• Villanova has lost each of its last three night games after coming off overtime.
• Villanova has lost the first half in each of its last three night games at Prudential Center against non-AP-ranked opponents.

Why the Villanova Wildcats will win

• Villanova has won each of its last nine games against non-AP-ranked opponents.
• Seton Hall has lost each of its last six home night games against the Big East Conference.
• Seton Hall has lost the first half in seven of its last eight home night games against the Big East Conference.

Villanova vs Seton Hall Prediction

I’ll stick with Villanova but you could call this one either way. It’ll be a fun matchup. The Wildcats had a close call versus Wisconsin in their last outing but everything ended up working out in overtime. Villanova shot a tepid 40 percent from the field in that one with 13-of-19 (68.4 percent) from the line and just seven turnovers. The Wildcats have scored 70 or more points in all nine of their wins this year, so getting to that threshold in this one will be crucial.

As for Seton Hall, they put up 45.5 percent shooting with a 31-26 rebounding edge on Providence in their last game. The Pirates weren’t great from the line (17-of-27 for 63 percent) however, and did have 12 turnovers. Seton Hall has 68 or more points in every game now, with 72 or more points in seven straight outings. This one will be a pretty high total if both teams can stay on point.

Andrew Jett's Pick: Villanova Wildcats +1.5