New York Giants vs Buffalo Bills Prediction 8/9/2025 Today’s NFL Picks

In this article, we will formulate a Giants vs Bills prediction for this NFL game on Saturday, August 9th at Highmark Stadium in Orchard Park, NY. Let’s take a look at the prediction for this Week 1 matchup in the preseason.

New York Giants Team Preview

The New York Giants are looking forward to a more successful 2025 after enduring a difficult season last year. New York wrapped up the previous season with a 3-14 record, which placed them last in the NFC East standings. In the offseason, the Giants took steps to fill their quarterback position by signing Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston. Wilson is not expected to participate on Saturday, along with the majority of the Giants’ starting players.

Winston might make an appearance, but the spotlight will be on rookie quarterback Jaxon Dart. The No. 25 overall pick is set to make his professional debut on Saturday. Additionally, linebacker Abdul Carter, selected at No. 3, will also be a key rookie to watch. The Giants will be missing their star wide receiver Malik Nabers, who did not engage in the final segments of Wednesday’s practice. Nabers is a player to monitor in the regular season, as he is coming off a Pro Bowl-caliber season in his rookie year.

Buffalo Bills Team Preview

The Buffalo Bills are returning to action. The team that is currently featured in HBO’s Hard Knocks this year is aiming for another significant playoff run after last year’s AFC Championship appearance. The Bills come back with a well-rounded roster, but not many key players will be participating in Saturday’s preseason opener. The reigning MVP, Josh Allen, will not be playing in the first preseason game of the season. The Bills have decided to rest their star player to ensure his health. Mitch Trubisky will start the game against the Giants. Last season, Trubisky played in nine games, completing 19 of 26 passes for a total of 179 yards. He only played a few snaps last year when the games were already out of reach.

As the roster continues to change in the latter half of the game, quarterbacks Mike White and Shane Buechele will also see action for the Bills. Coach McDermott stated that starters will play no more than one quarter. It’s time to expect some younger players from Buffalo in this matchup. The Bills’ only 1st round draft pick, cornerback Maxwell Hairston, is likely to miss the game due to a knee injury sustained during camp last week.

Giants vs Bills Prediction

In this game, the Giants and Bills are expected to limit the participation of their starters as both teams aim to stay healthy. Analyzing the backup players, it appears that the Giants have a considerable edge in experience at key positions, which could be pivotal. The Giants will have Jameis Winston and Tommy DeVito taking the snaps at quarterback, while a determined Jaxon Dart is poised to make significant contributions. Furthermore, I foresee Abdul Carter making an immediate impact on the defensive front as well. The Bills will be resting several key players from last year’s playoff run, including Josh Allen. The quarterback duo of Mike White and Mitch Trubisky may not provide the necessary firepower and agility to secure extra yards for Buffalo. This matchup is likely to be tightly contested between two teams that will deploy many players who are not expected to see much action in the regular season. I lean towards the team with the more talented rookies. Thus, I suggest backing the Giants to cover the spread.