MLB Player Prop Picks (National League Pitchers) 9/12/2025 Today’s MLB Picks

Brady Singer Over 2.5 Earned Runs
Cincinnati Reds vs Athletics 10:05 PM EST

Brady Singer has been putting together a solid season with the Cincinnati Reds, establishing himself as a reliable rotation arm. He comes into this one with a 13-9 record with a 3.98 ERA and a 1.26 WHIP, while striking out 145 batters. His advanced metrics show opponents are averaging around 90.3 mph exit velocity against him, with a 40.3% hard-hit rate and an 8.8% barrel rate, numbers that suggest some solid contact but not overwhelmingly damaging. Singer has been great as of late but I want to fade him in this spot. This ballpark in Sacramento has been brutal on pitchers and Singer has been much worse on the road than at home this season. 

Check out Brad’s BEST PICKS, including his $19 PICK OF THE DAY!

Quinn Priester Over 4.5 K’s
St. Louis Cardinals vs Milwaukee Brewers 8:10 PM EST

Quinn Priester has had a strong 2025 season so far. He comes into this one with a 12-2 record, posting a 3.25 ERA, striking out 113 batters, and carrying a WHIP of 1.23. In his last 15 starts, he went 9-0, with a 2.84 ERA and 1.18 WHIP over 85.2 innings. I’ve loved what I’ve seen from Priester as of late, and he’s been great when playing in Milwaukee this season. He is coming off a 6-strikeout performance against the Pirates, and I expect him to carry that momentum into this one. St. Louis just hasn’t been the same team on the road and has been strikeout-heavy on the road as well. Let’s back Priester to rack up some strikeouts. 

Tanner Gordon Over 2.5 Earned Runs
Colorado Rockies vs San Diego Padres 9:40 PM EST

Tanner Gordon has had a tough season to say the least. Over 12 starts, he has a 5–6 win–loss record with an ERA of 6.60. He’s thrown 60.0 innings, struck out 46 batters, and posted a 1.60 WHIP. We saw Gordon face this Padres team just last week, and the Padres were able to get 6 runs off him. You would expect Gordon’s number to be inflated when pitching at Coors Field, but he’s actually been far worse on the road this season. Even though these Padres bats have been spotty as of late, I do expect them to get after a pitcher like Gordon.