Cleveland Cavaliers vs Indiana Pacers Player Prop Picks 5/9/25 NBA Picks

Indiana Pacers (50-32) vs Cleveland Cavaliers (64-18)

Game Info: Friday, May 9, 2025 at 7:30 pm (Gainbridge Fieldhouse)

Betting Odds: Indiana Pacers +2.5 -- Over/Under: 229.5 Click Here for the Latest Odds

Where to Watch: ESPN

The Cleveland Cavaliers and Indiana Pacers are set to face off in Game 3 of their Eastern Conference Semifinals series on Friday, May 9, 2025, at 7:30 PM ET at Gainbridge Fieldhouse in Indianapolis. The Pacers lead the series 2–0 after securing two road victories in Cleveland.

In Game 1, the Pacers defeated the Cavaliers 121–112, and in Game 2, they edged out a 120–119 victory, with Myles Turner leading Indiana with 23 points. Donovan Mitchell led Cleveland with 48 points in Game 2. The Cavaliers have been hampered by injuries to key players, including Darius Garland (toe), Evan Mobley (ankle), and De'Andre Hunter (thumb), while Donovan Mitchell is playing through a calf strain.

Check out Brad’s BEST PICKS, including his $19 PICK OF THE DAY!

Donovan Mitchell Over 29.5 Points

Over 71 regular-season games, he averaged 24.0 points, 5.0 assists, and 4.5 rebounds per game. His shooting splits included 44.3% from the field, 36.8% from three-point range, and 82.3% from the free-throw line. During the playoffs, Mitchell elevated his performance, averaging 29.3 points, 4.8 assists, and 3.8 rebounds over six games.  His postseason contributions underscored his role as a key leader for the Cavaliers during their playoff run. With the injuries Cleveland is dealing with, Mitchell is carrying this offense on his back. He cleared this line with ease in games 1 & 2, he won’t slow down in this one. 

Aaron Nesmith Over 12.5 Points

Nesmith is averaging 12.0 points, 4.0 rebounds, and 1.2 assists per game. Nesmith showcased impressive shooting percentages, hitting 50.7% from the field, 43.1% from three-point range, and 91.3% from the free-throw line. Nesmith has been great for Indiana so far in these playoffs. He scored 14+ points in the Pacers last 6 games and is coming off a 17 point game in game 1 and a 23 point game in game 2 of this series. I’ll ride with the hot hand until he cools off. 

Jarrett Allen Over 13.5 Points

Allen is averaging 13.5 points per game, ranking 76th in the league. His scoring was notably efficient, leading the NBA with a field goal percentage of 70.6%, underscoring his effectiveness around the rim. In the playoffs, Allen elevated his scoring, averaging 15.2 points over six games. He’s scored 14+ points in 3 of his last 4 games and is coming off a 22 points game in game 2. With their being questions about Mobley’s availability, Allen will have to lead this Cav’s frontcourt.

The pick in this article is the opinion of the writer, not a PickDawgz site consensus.

18+ Has gambling become a problem for you? Call the National Problem Gambling Hotline.
1-800-522-4700 | ncpgambling.org

Credit Guaranteed Packages

Packages with Credit Guarantees automatically give you a credit if the package does not turn a profit—the sum of betting all individual picks. THESE ARE NOT PARLAYS UNLESS OTHERWISE CLEARLY STATED. If a credit guaranteed package does not profit, a credit for its full purchase price is automatically issued after picks are graded and verified.

For example, if you purchase a $39.95 package that doesn’t profit, you’ll get a $39.95 credit towards any future purchase(s) on our site. Credits are usually issued within hours of a game’s conclusion, so please allow a few hours for final verification.

To use your credits, log in to your account and add another package or pass to your cart. Credits will automatically reduce what you owe. Any remaining balance will be settled through our payment system, with any leftover credits available future purchases. Credits do not expire.

Dismiss