Yankees vs Blue Jays Prediction - MLB Picks 5/16/23

Toronto Blue Jays (24-17) vs New York Yankees (24-19)

Game Info: Tuesday, May 16, 2023 at 7:07 pm (Rogers Centre)

Kevin Gausman (2-3) (3.37) vs Domingo German (2-3) (4.00)

Betting Odds: Toronto Blue Jays -175 / New York Yankees +145 --- Over/Under: 8.5 Click Here for the Latest Odds

Where to Watch: MLB.tv Stream the MLB Game of the Day all season on ESPN+. Sign up now! Advertisement

The New York Yankees will play the Toronto Blue Jays in Game 2 of their series on Tuesday night at the Rogers Centre in Toronto, Ontario.

Yankees Preview

The New York Yankees are 24-19 this season and they have won six of their last eight games. New York won Game 1 of this series by a score of 7-4 on Monday night. The New York pitching staff has a 3.89 ERA, a 1.25 WHIP, and a .233 opponent batting average this year. The Yankees offense has scored 199 runs with a .238 batting average and a .312 on base percentage. Aaron Judge is batting .274 with 10 home runs and 24 RBI’s for the Yankees. The projected starting pitcher for New York is Domingo German, who is 2-3 with a 4.00 ERA and a 0.96 WHIP over 45.0 innings pitched this season.

Blue Jays Preview

The Toronto Blue Jays are 24-17 this season and they have won three of their last four games. Prior to losing the first game in this series, Toronto won all three games in their series with the Braves. The Toronto pitching staff has a 4.01 ERA, a 1.28 WHIP, and a .239 opponent batting average. The Blue Jays offense has scored 196 runs with a .258 batting average and a .331 on base percentage this season. Bo Bichette is batting .324 with eight home runs and 27 RBI’s for the Blue Jays. The projected starting pitcher for Toronto is Kevin Gausman, who is 2-3 with a 3.38 ERA and a 1.10 WHIP over 48.0 innings pitched this year. 

See which Cappers are CASHING IN.. Click Here to see the HOTTEST CAPPERS!!!!


New York is 6-2 in their last 8 games and 41-17 in their last 58 Tuesday games. The over is 9-0 in New York’s last 9 games. Toronto is 8-2 in their last 10 home games and 0-5 in their last 5 games against the AL East. The under is 8-2 in Toronto’s last 10 game two’s of a series. New York is 12-4 in these two teams last 16 head to head meetings in Toronto.


The Yankees were able to get an impressive win in Game 1 of this series after Toronto was able to sweep the Braves over the weekend. Both teams are playing very well recently and they have very similar hitting and pitching metrics. New York is starting Domingo German, who has allowed two earned runs or fewer in three straight starts. Toronto is starting Kevin Gausman, who has allowed 0 earned runs in three of his last four starts, but did allow eight runs to Boston two starts ago. This is a very solid pitching matchup and I like the under here. 

Take Your Betting Game And Winning To the NEXT LEVEL Call PickDawgz at 888-419-0435 or Click Here for MORE INFORMATION

The pick in this article is the opinion of the writer, not a PickDawgz site consensus.

Mitch's Take...

MLB Best Bets for Today Picks & Predictions Tuesday 6/6/23 | 7 Picks in 5 Minutes

Credit Guaranteed Packages

Packages with Credit Guarantees automatically give you a credit if the package does not turn a profit—the sum of betting all individual picks. THESE ARE NOT PARLAYS UNLESS OTHERWISE CLEARLY STATED. If a credit guaranteed package does not profit, a credit for its full purchase price is automatically issued after picks are graded and verified.

For example, if you purchase a $39.95 package that doesn’t profit, you’ll get a $39.95 credit towards any future purchase(s) on our site. Credits are usually issued within hours of a game’s conclusion, so please allow a few hours for final verification.

To use your credits, log in to your account and add another package or pass to your cart. Credits will automatically reduce what you owe. Any remaining balance will be settled through our payment system, with any leftover credits available future purchases. Credits do not expire.